The etymology of ketchup is unclear. As far as I can tell, it originates as the phonetic spelling of a poorly-translated language-specific term or phrase. If someone tried to translate and explain the phrase “Yippee-ki-yay motherfucker” in, say, Mandarin; I imagine the reaction would be one of befuddlement. Yet, as Americans, we all know its implied meaning. So fine, who knows where the word came from? Ketchup, catsup…whatever. Or as I’m calling it, “catsuck”, because I hate cats. I’ll come up with my own spelling, thank you.
And when I emptied the last of the Heinz ketchup bottle and began to add it to the grocery list, I decided instead to make my own product, too. Heinz may be the gold standard, but it’s not a holder of forgotten secrets. I mean, it’s ketchup, not WD-40. My mother-in-law makes it. A local restaurant makes it. So surely I can make it, too.
But I needed a benchmark to start with. It was off to the internet for generic recipe guidance! Here’s what I found as a basic ingredients list:
- Tomatoes (my own garden tomatoes in fact)
- Sugar
- White vinegar
- Onion powder
- Garlic powder
- Salt
- Celery salt
- Mustard powder
- Black pepper
- Cayenne
- Cloves
I did not add the cayenne. That seemed wrong. Also the cloves alone seemed lacking a counterpart. And the vinegar lacked substance. And the final texture was kind of watery. If I wanted a Heinz facsimile, but better, some tweaking was needed. Here was my final list after some hours of simmering and sampling:
- Tomatoes
- Sugar
- White vinegar
- Apple cider vinegar
- Onion powder
- Garlic powder
- Salt
- Celery salt
- Mustard powder
- White pepper
- Cloves
- Allspice
- MSG
- Xantan gum
The only measurement I’d define as crucial is the vinegar/tomato ratio:
- 2 quarts tomato sauce
- 3/4 cup white vinegar
- 1/4 cup apple cider vinegar
After that, it’s add as you go while it simmers in a crock pot until happy with the flavor. Process in blender for smoothness (although when I did this, the blender pour spout popped open and spewed ketchup across the living room – don’t do that).

For added convenience, and to add that restaurant factor, I stored it in a food-grade squeeze bottle.
It even passed the family taste test. Version 1.0 appears to be a success. Now I just hope I can replicate it again.
–Simon










